Not a dealer · Not investment advice
Gold and silver dealers, compared on what you pay over spot.
Each dealer's published prices, card-versus-wire gap, shipping, buyback minimums and storage fees, side by side, with the record behind each one. We don't sell metal, take orders or offer gold IRAs. If you're new to this, start with how spot prices and premiums work; if someone is pressing you to buy, read the red flags first.
What we compare, and how
Premium over spot
What a standard 1 oz coin or bar cost on the dealer's own page on the day we checked, against the spot price that day, at the cheapest payment method and at the card price.
Payment and fees
The gap between card and wire prices, shipping and insurance on a small first order, order minimums and what happens if you cancel after the price is locked.
Buyback
Whether the dealer buys back, its minimum, how the price is locked and how long payment takes. A dealer you can't easily sell to costs you on the way out.
Storage
Whether it offers vault storage, at what rate, whether metal is segregated in your name, and the fees to take it out.
Record
Regulator actions, lawsuits and data breaches involving the dealer or its owner, linked, with what was alleged and how it ended where we could confirm it.
Five online bullion dealers, side by side
Dealers whose full price tiers and buyback terms we could read come first: APMEX, whose rules we found the most complete, then SD Bullion. JM Bullion publishes its payment discounts and buyback terms, but its product pages blocked our price check, so it comes third. BGASC follows; it is a storefront run by JM Bullion under the same owner and processes orders the same way. Kitco sits last because its $15 shipping on orders under $5,000, its 0.65% insurance on every order, and its $5,000 minimum to sell back (five times APMEX's, JM Bullion's and BGASC's) weigh most on a first, small purchase. Prices are as each dealer published them on Nov 21, 2026 (a Saturday, so spot was Friday's close); on weekdays they change every few seconds.
Affiliate disclosure: some links to the platforms on Metals.now may earn us a commission if you sign up or pay. It never costs you more, and no platform pays to be listed or to change what we write. How we rate
| Platform | Best for | Premiums & fees | Payment & shipping | Buyback & storage | Regulators & complaints | Links |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| APMEXOnline bullion and coin dealer | First-time and repeat buyers who want every price tier, payment discount and buyback rule in writing before they order. | Gold Eagle ≈6.9% over spot (check/wire) | 4.0% cash discount; card ≈4.2% more | Buys back from $1,000; storage 0.55%/yr, $15/mo min. | No action found | |
| SD BullionOnline bullion dealer | Price-checkers paying by e-check or wire who want published buyback bids and cheap segregated storage. | Gold Eagle ≈5.3% over spot (check/wire) | Cards up to $5,000; no Amex | Buys 2 oz gold / 40 oz silver up; storage from $9.99/mo | Class action over "lowest price" ads (2025) | |
| JM BullionOnline bullion dealer | Buyers who want the widest catalog, many payment options and a sell-back price they can lock online at any hour. | 4% cash discount; product prices not readable by us | Cards to $250K; wire from $500 | Buys from $1,000; storage via TDS | 2020 card-skimming breach | |
| BGASCOnline bullion and coin dealer | Buyers who already shop JM Bullion and want a second price from the same warehouse, or graded coins from an official PCGS dealer. | 4% cash discount; compare to JM | Wire $1K–$250K; checks to $75K | Buys from $1,000; no storage found | Owner's record as JM Bullion | |
| KitcoCanadian bullion dealer selling to the US | Larger buyers (over $5,000) who want an established non-US dealer and storage outside the US. | $15 shipping under $5K; 0.65% insurance on all | Card or PayPal to $10K (new customers) | Buys from $5,000; storage in Canada and Hong Kong | Canadian tax dispute, creditor protection (2011) |
Facts last checked November 2026. Each platform's review page lists the sources.
Latest guides
Gold bars vs coins: premiums, resale and reporting
Gold bars vs coins compared on real Nov 2026 prices: premium per ounce, fractional sizes, resale, 1099-B reporting and the collectible-coin pitch to avoid.Gold vs silver: premiums, storage space and sales tax
Gold vs silver for physical buyers, on facts not forecasts: premiums over spot, how much $10,000 of each weighs, sales tax rules, selling minimums and taxes.How to sell gold and silver: buyback spreads and 1099-B
How to sell gold and silver bullion: dealer buyback minimums and payment times, what the spread costs, when a dealer files IRS Form 1099-B, and what you owe.Gold and silver taxes: the 28% collectibles rate explained
How the IRS taxes gains on gold and silver bullion: the 28% collectibles rate, short-term gains, the 3.8% NIIT, cost basis, losses and Form 8949 reporting.How to store gold and silver: safe, bank box or vault
Storing gold and silver at home, in a bank safe deposit box or a depository: insurance limits, FDIC rules, vault fees, and segregated vs non-segregated storage.Physical gold vs GLD (and SLV): what you actually own
How owning gold coins or bars differs from GLD or SLV shares: ownership, expense ratio vs premiums and storage, delivery, custody risk and the 28% tax rate.Four numbers worth knowing before you buy
5.3% over spot was the price of a 1 oz Gold Eagle at SD Bullion by check or wire on Nov 21, 2026 ($3,735.79 against $3,549.23 spot).
4% is the discount every dealer here gives for paying by check or wire instead of card or PayPal. On a $10,000 order, that's $400.
6.8% is what you'd lose per coin buying that coin and selling it straight back the same day at SD Bullion's published bid ($3,480.66, listed for sales over 10 oz), before shipping.
28% is the top federal capital-gains rate on long-term gains from gold and silver, which the IRS taxes as collectibles, not as stocks. The 3.8% net investment income tax can apply on top.
Sources: SD Bullion Gold Eagle prices, SD Bullion bid prices, APMEX user agreement, IRS Topic 409, IRS Topic 559. Report precious-metals fraud to the CFTC, and see gold and silver taxes for how the 28% rate works.